Fast Food Nation: An Appetite for Litigation
Fast Food Nation: An Appetite for Litigation
Fast Food Nation: An Appetite for Litigation
US Lawyer John Banzhaf Was the First to Sue the Tobacco Companies in the mid-Sixties. Now He Wants to Prosecute the Junk-Food Industry for Making Americans Obese
by Andrew Gumbel
John Banzhaf likes to pose this challenge to students who enroll in his graduate class on legal activism at George Washington University, in Washington, DC. Think of something that really irritates you or smacks of obvious civil injustice, he tells them. Then think of a way of using the law to right the wrong and seek redress.
In other words, as Professor Banzhaf himself puts it with the freewheeling candor we have come to expect from both heroes and villains in the American legal system, lets sue the bastards.
Its a unique approach to legal education that has had some astonishing results down the years. Banzhafs students successfully forced the stuffy Washington Cosmos Club to admit women for the first time, and got dry-cleaners to stop charging women more than men for laundering their shirts. Back in the 1970s, they sued Spiro Agnew, the Vice-President who left office in disgrace shortly before his boss, Richard Nixon, forcing him to return the bribes he had received.
Most famously, Banzhaf pioneered the notion of suing tobacco companies for the deleterious health consequences of smoking. He started doing it in the mid-1960s, when everyone thought he was nuts, and he was still doing it in 1998 when the US states successfully pried hundreds of millions of dollars out of the Big Five tobacco companies as compensation for their smoking-related health-care costs. If tobacco advertising is now banned on television, and smoking no longer tolerated on planes or in shops and restaurants in many parts of the United States, it is largely due to Banzhafs 35 years of campaigning and savvy application of public-interest law.
And now, he has a new target: the junk-food industry. America, as we all know, is the fattest nation on the planet and getting fatter all the time. According to a report by the US Surgeon-General, released a few months ago, 61 per cent of Americans are now significantly overweight, compared with 55 per cent in the early 1990s, and 46 per cent in the late 1970s. Obesity generates $117bn in annual medical bills and triggers 300,000 premature deaths each year.
Is this a health problem on a par with the effects of tobacco-smoking? Banzhaf thinks so, and the governments figures are there to bear him out. Can the fast-food companies and the agribusiness giants, the packagers and marketers, be held responsible for the problem? Banzhaf argues that they are certainly the ones stuffing the nations consumers full of fat, sugar and chemical additives. With a little statistical analysis, he believes, it should be possible to assign specific shares of the blame to specific companies.
And so, he is embarking on a new adventure in legal activism. Already, his graduate class has inspired one lawsuit, against McDonalds, and at least three others are in the works around the country. And that is just the beginning. As a recent magazine headline memorably put it, he wants to see whether Americans can sue their own fat asses off.
Banzhaf, it must be said, is far from your stereotypical litigation lawyer, forever looking out for an opportunity to screw a corporation or public institution and make a fast buck. Not only does he not make a penny from the suits that he inspires, he would, in fact, much rather not bring them in the first place. He would love it if the government would overhaul the food industry to make Americans