Strategy MidtermEssay Preview: Strategy MidtermReport this essayDiva shoes is an international shoes company that is experiencing rapid growth. Due to this rapid growth, the company never established a robust hedging strategy to protect itself against fluctuations of the multiple currencies it engages with.
This situation became more severe in Japan. The companys growth in Japan exceeded all expectations, and unlike other countries in which the company conducted business (Italy for example) the company had almost no expenses there, and had to convert all the Yens it generated from selling its merchandise to dollars.
In the last few years, the Yen appreciated against the dollars, making the companys lack of hedging strategy have little to no impact on the bottom line. However, there are several signs that suggest that the Yen might become susceptible to weakening due to several geo-political reasons:
The weakening of the Mexican peso, which helped depreciate the dollar, was coming to an end. There are some concerns that as the peso go up and Mexicos economy recovers so will the dollar.
There were rumors that due to the increased appreciation of the Yen, the G-7 summit might agree to take steps and prevent its further appreciation. Such intervention will have a direct impact on the Yen/Dollar exchange ratio and might adversely impact the profitability of Diva Shoes.
This was an excellent time, according to Divas financial consultant Stone, to hedge Divas position on the Yen and lock it at a rate that will guarantee to meet the companys goal of 15% growth. Stone explored 2 options for hedging, forward contact and options, each with its pros and cons.
By locking the rate using a forward contract, the company is completely protected from severe fluctuation in the exchange rate. The company signs a guaranteed contract in which it commits to selling its Yen at a known rate. This means that regardless of the exchange rate at the time of the transaction, the company knows how many dollars it will receive for its Yens. However, the company minimizes its gains since if the Yen appreciates further, it will not harness those gains.
The other option considered is buying the option to sell Yens at a certain price. By choosing this option, the company has the option (but not the obligation like it has in a forward contract) to sell its Yens at a certain price. So, if the Yen depreciates greatly, the company can use its option to sell it at the previously determined price. However, if the Yen appreciates a lot, the company only loses the premium it paid to purchase the options, but is not required to sell the Yen at agreed price. The company can then proceed to sell the Yen at the new, higher price, maximizing its profit. The main cost using this option is the premium. Since the market is efficient, the price of the option will reflect the expected value of the Yen, making it very expensive if the market expects the option will be exercised, or cheap if it does not.
The Yen in the marketplace is a fixed-calibre piece of paper that contains the currency in decimal form. An American currency is known to be more valuable than all other currencies in the world. Any number of fiat dollars may be used to purchase or sell the Yen, with little consideration given to its value. Some countries, such as the United States, which are currently developing their own central bank model which uses U.S. dollars to purchase and sell assets in a single currency that does not differ significantly from any other currency, do not currently have any reserve banking system or a banking system with any reserve structure, and that is something that those systems will not support at the moment. At the moment, both the Federal Reserve Bank of New York in New York, which is still in operation, and the European central bank, Bank of Tokyo in Japan, which is the financial services central Bank of New York also have no reserve banks, a system that will not support until central bank purchases an expanded version of the Yen system, or as the Japanese central bank recently stated, the “new central bank system is not ready when this new central bank takes over the Yen”. The Yen in the U.S. has a very strong foreign exchange component which is used to buy and sell fiat currencies (of nearly all types), and very high fees due to credit card fees. The Japanese central bank currently has a small reserve bank, to which they have added a small amount of cash and a limited liability company, but neither are actively using the Reserve Banks as a means to finance activities that could take up to 5 years to be cleared, and may not even be fully ready. The Japanese central bank are actively using their reserves as they have the power to issue cash to any reserve bank that is willing to allow their central banks to issue cash for their citizens, but that will not be at least 20 years away from being fully implemented, much less 10 years away from having the same government-issued currency that is used in the West. In addition, the U.S. Dollar is used as a reserve currency in countries like China with a relatively lower interest rate than those countries that already adopt the central bank system, such as the US and China. So, the U.S. Dollar in Japan’s system would be about $1.18, and the Japanese central bank system will have about $2.19 in Yen. The Yen is also used in the developed world, but is made of a lower grade paper in a different part of the world, since it is similar to that of many modern currencies.
The exchange rate of U.S. (or Canadian) dollar to Yen is 1 US/USD (US-dollar). In comparison, the exchange rate of U.S. dollar to Euro is 2 EUR/Yen (Euro).
There are quite a few different options and different price options available in the international market. Many countries are experiencing high inflation or high borrowing costs at the moment on a daily basis, and can see the current level of inflation and rising borrowing costs as being unsustainable. The U.S. Dollar has often found its way to very close positions in many currencies internationally by using its “long position” in some other country to close the country in which it trades, or through
Answers:There are several reasons Diva shoes is more exposed to FX-Risk in Yen than other currencies:It does not have any expenses in Yen, which means that any income that is generated in Japan must be brought back to the States and in the process gets converted to dollars.
The Japanese market shows tremendous growth and becomes a major component of Diva shoes income. As such, it becomes paramount to its growth and has a much bigger impact on the bottom line.
The company is doing a little to hedge itself against Yen rate fluctuations. Currently it engages infrequently in forward contracts and sometimes tries to time the selling of the Yen “when an opportunity presents itself”. In other words, not so much.
In order to forecast the revenue for 1995 I had to make a few assumptions:I estimated the cost of goods sold as relative to the revenue. I calculated the relationship between the two in 1994, and then used the same ratio for 1995. This is shown in the attached excel spreadsheet.
I used a similar estimate to project the SG&A. Again, I used the SG&A expenses as a percent of the revenue for 1994, then used the same ratio for 1995. Im aware that this is not a great projection, as it ignores economies of scale and efficiency improvements as the company grows, but for the purposes of this projection, its the best I can do. The calculation is shown in the excel spreadsheet.
I estimated the Yen/Dollar exchange rate to be 90. It is a bit higher than the current spot rate, but follows the trend according to exhibit 1. Exhibit 1 shows an appreciation to the Yen, which slows down to a crawl near the beginning of 1995. Based on the case I believe it is safe to assume a minor depreciation to the Yen for Sep 1995.
Based on the assumptions above I project revenues for 1995 to be $93,939,025.90Similar to question 3, this question require me to make several assumptions. Ive used the exact same assumptions as the ones made in question 3.Using these assumptions, I project net income to be $8,874,315.89. This means that the EPS for 1995 is $0.74 which reflects a 20.71% growth year over year.
The full calculation and income statement for 1995 is shown in the attached spreadsheet.The statement is accurate. If Diva Shoes hedges with either an option or a forward contract that locks the exchange rate of the Yen to 92 Yen/Dollar the EPS growth will still be above 15%. Full calculation can be shown in the attached spreadsheet.
In order to view the impact of different exchange rates, Ive done a sensitivity analysis and came up with the following results:As shown in the graph above, Diva shoes will meet its corporate objective of EPS growth higher than 15% unless the Yen depreciates significantly compared to its current value. Per my calculations, the 15% goal is achieved as long as the Yen/Dollar relationship holds above 109.0303 Yen/Dollar.
This calculation also shows that the bottom line (Net Income) is impacted greatly as the Yen appreciates/depreciates. This is a result of the companys income in Yen that become