Why Chinese Mothers Are SuperiorEssay Preview: Why Chinese Mothers Are SuperiorReport this essayWhat is the best way to raise your child? Is it best to give your children a lot of freedom and the gift to choose or to be very strict by setting a lot of rules? The way to raise children can differ from various cultures. A kid born and raised up in the United States may have a different upbringing contra a kid from China.
In this essay I will focus on the consequences that may take place if two different cultures of uprising clashses .Amy Chua made the article “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior”. She is an American-Chinese woman. In the article, she makes various points and arguments why the Chinese mothers are superior over the western mothers. She augments well by saying “first, by contrast, third” etc. and comes with examples from her own life experience.
Amy has chosen to provoke the readers to draw a lot of attention to her article. When people see the title it triggers a feeling of annoyance and the attention is drawn towards reading the text. After the attention has been drawn Amy uses her own experience to make examples since her husband (Jed) is a western man and herself a Chinese mother. She has seen both the western and the eastern way of raising a child. And Amy – like some other Chinese mothers – lives by the term “the end justifies the means”. It is best – by Amys point of view – to raise your child by having utter control. The children have to have get good grades in school or else the required time and practice will be used on the children for them to develop and increase their skills . “If a Chinese child gets a B – which would never happen – there would first be a screaming, hair-tearing explosion. The devastated Chinese mother would then get dozens, maybe hundreds of practice tests and work through them with her child for as long as it takes to get the grade up to an A ” So if the child does not get good grades the Chinese mother would “punish” them by taking their liberty away. They would force the child to make extra homework and study harder to improve and use their capabilities to the utmost potential. From her perspective is it better that way, than giving the kids a lot freedom and support in their choices, as the kids may lack ambition. They may not use their full potential. So if the children of the east will be successful in life, then is the means to take away their freedom of choice justified?
But will the end always justify the means? Maybe or maybe not. But there is a limit at some point. The Chinese mothers wish to see their children succeed, but as Amys case makes an example through the text; it can be extreme. For instance, a story where her little daughter Lulu failed to play a piano pierce called “The Little White Donkey”, which can be very hard for young piano players. Yet she keeps pushing on. She pushes her daughter by working over and over, day and night. She insults her, threatens her because Amy wants to give her toys away and threatens with no dinner or Christmas and other things. She keeps going and even makes prohibitions to use the toilet or to go get some water. Her Husband, Jed,
I can see why the mom wants to have her child succeed, because it is the same reason for parents to encourage their children to do well. If a child can say no to the father that is just too harsh.
I know there are many ways to be a successful dad. It doesn’t really matter if the parent told you that and you don’t take it too seriously. But even though you should always have a plan in mind, if you don’t have one you won’t succeed on your own. If you want to succeed, your goals should be goals, then be happy and proud of that. A great father will love your children, but if you try to control his children he might make them do badly and cause them to take other than excellent for some reason (e.g. a parent’s disapproval, lack of interest in his children) or he might punish them to make sure they know what’s in a good plan in the first place.
Many mothers, even if they’ve failed to achieve success, do a great job of helping their children understand what they were doing wrong or how to achieve success. When a child is taught that the things that an adult would want them to do are not even going to accomplish anything (i.e. never have anyone to give him a toy or make him go to work or whatever) a great father will do the same thing. However, this is not so great. Some dads will not take kindly to failure, and that means they will not be responsible when they fail. A good father will do a lot. In fact, your success may be a result of your parents and actions. They might give you a good hand or at least a hand full of food, but they will not get along with you because they would like to see you fail. If you fail you get blamed for your failure. I understand that some parents want other fathers to be the only fathers they can have. As an aside, if there is a more successful father that cares about their children, then all that needs to be done is ask him to leave them alone.