Othello and Identity
Essay Preview: Othello and Identity
Report this essay
Identity is a very key, important thematic issue in William Shakespeares tragic drama, Othello. Identity, or what may be better explained as a characters public perception, is highly valued in the Elizabethan Age in which Othello is set. There is a varying range between the characters in the extent that how they are perceived in public is not how they behave in private or how they really are, thus creating more than one identity per character. A characters identity is the overall essence of that character, however, in plays such as Shakespeares there must always be an element of tragic flaw to the play thus creating conflict. In Othello, conflict ultimately arises through the plotting and scheming of one central, manipulative character representative of evil, Iago. The characters whose individual identities are seen as important issues in the drama can be identified as Othello, Iago, and Desdemona, respectively. Therefore, the element of identity in Othello, Iago, and Desdemona are important to a great extreme when discussing the thematic relevance of identity to Shakespeares Othello as a whole.
Othellos perception of identity varies greatly from that of Iago in that he saw people differently and also had a complete opposite identity to Iago. Othellos character is a combination of greatness and weakness. This can almost appear to be an oxymoron but through careful speculation of the text it can be proven. Othello himself says that he is “An honorable murderer” (Act V.2, 299). Othello was great, to a certain extent. He was great in the fact that he was a great warrior, earning the title of General in the Venetian defense forces. However, this feat was greater than the initial sounds of it due to the fact that Othello was originally a slave from Africa, but he had now long ago adapted to the Venetian society. While on topic, Othellos public perception was that of an outsider due to his social insecurities. There was the quality of the “Moor” within him, and as accepted and honored as he was; he was also essentially separated from the people he shared life with. Not only was he different by origin, but also his skin color was a different color, serving as a permanent and constant reminder to all those living amongst him. This can be seen through the dialectic of other characters in discussion of “him,” Othello. In the beginning of the play, he is referred to as “he” or terms identifying him with the color of his skin such as Moor, black, etc. All other characters are referred to by their personal names. However, besides this idea of an element of racism towards Othello, others perceive him in no other way than great and honorable as can be seen here, “Here comes Barbantio and the valiant Moor” (Act I.3, 47) Not only does he posses great character and courage, but also dignity. He keeps his control even when he is being accused of witchcraft during the first encounter with the senators when Desdemonas father, Barbantio, confronts Othello about the supposed engagement between his daughter and Othello (Act I.3, 76-82):
Most potent, grave, and reverend signors,
My very noble and approved good masters;
That I have taen away this old mans daughter,
It is most true; true I have married her.
The very head and front of my offending
Hath the extent, no more. Rude I am in my speech,
And little blessed with the soft phrase of peace.
Thanks to his public perception, it wasnt hard for other people to accept the relationship between him and Desdemona. However, as Iago begins to place the seed of doubt into Othello about an adulterous relationship forming between Cassio, his close friend and recently promoted lieutenant, and Desdemona, the audience is able to view the surfacing of another side of Othellos personality. Since Iago had the public perception, or identity, of being an honest man, Othello simply ignore the claims made against his fiancй. It started an unraveling of Othello, in a sense, because he became ultimately plagued from that moment on with a constant wondering of what the truth was and if Desdemona really loved him, or if she was just using him to rebel against her father. It is here that the audience begins seeing a different identity of Othello. Who was once regarded as so valiant and courageous, was now beginning to show signs of severe insecurities dealing with matters, most importantly, such as his lack of experience in love and marriage causing shadows of doubt over his confidence in himself and his ability to be loved by and worthy of someone like Desdemona. Desdemona, although not intentionally, seems to be the reason for all the unrest in Othello. This is an instance in the play when irony shines its smiling face upon Shakespeares most tragic characters. Othello feels truly happy with the presence of Desdemona in his life (Act II.1, 181-187):
It gives me wonder great as my content
To see you here before me. O! my souls joy,
If after every tempest come such calms,
May the winds blow till they have wakened death
And let the laboring bark climb hills of seas,
Olympus- high, and duck again as low
As hells from heaven! If it were now tow to die,
Twere now to be most happy;
And yet he also feels severe discontent with this same presence and feels that this love and triumph in his life is too good to be true and as all things too good to be true, cannot last, “But I do love thee, and when I love thee not,/ Chaos is come again” (Act III.3, 91-92).
Iagos perception of identity varies from Othellos in the fact that he is aware of his other identity, shall we say. The other identity being referred to here is the one that Iago has so carefully constructed in specificity towards destruction of and revenge towards Othello. Motivated by what can be lamely seen as bitterness in not receiving the position of lieutenant, and perhaps racial complexities towards Othello; Iago emerges as the supreme being of